Is the boring Monaco Grand Prix actually an issue? Aren’t Liberty Media simply going to drop it anyway subsequent yr as soon as its contract expires?
In spite of everything, the bombardment of hype round final yr’s Las Vegas Grand Prix assured us F1’s spectacular new occasion had taken the crown because the championship’s most glamorous race.
Maybe it has. However don’t underestimate the worth of heritage or the ability of jealousy. F1 followers might have lengthy come to affiliate the phrase ‘Monaco Grand Prix’ with 78 laps of tedium, however it has enormous world identify recognition and a rival collection might declare a publicity coup by taking it over.
Method E already has an occasion on the identical circuit, in spite of everything. And its narrower, slower vehicles can truly race across the principality’s streets.
F1 vehicles largely can’t, and so the annual post-Monaco Grand Prix argument over what could be carried out to enhance this spherical is in full swing. The same old cavalcade of half-baked knee-jerk Monaco-specific ‘fixes’ are being trotted out: ‘Extra obligatory pit stops’, ‘Power them to make use of tender tyres’, ‘Make them full a lap on foot’ and so forth.
The considering is that as a result of Monaco is such an uncommon circuit it wants it personal guidelines. However final weekend’s race was spoiled by questionable guidelines which have negatively affected different grands prix.
F1 tries to create thrilling races by forcing groups to make use of two completely different tyre compounds and hoping the pit stops this provokes result in modifications in place. However Monaco is such a gradual observe the tyres don’t put on out, and as overtaking there’s virtually inconceivable, the chief can again off by a number of seconds per lap to scale back the possibility a rival behind will be capable of time their pit cease as a way to assault them.
Even so, in an unusual Monaco Grand Prix the chasing pack has an opportunity to get forward, for instance by a fortuitously-timed Security Automobile interval. Max Verstappen and the Mercedes drivers gambled on this on Sunday, taking the beginning on the exhausting tyre compound, intending to remain out longer than the medium-shod Ferraris and McLarens forward.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
That intrigue was destroyed on the primary lap, together with Sergio Perez’s Purple Bull. His race-stopping collision with the Haas drivers allowed everybody to vary tyres and run to the tip.
It’s baffling that F1 has for years used the obligatory pit cease in an try and create racing motion, but nonetheless permits groups to get round it throughout pink flags intervals on this means. After all drivers ought to have the possibility to vary tyres throughout race suspensions for security causes, however they need to no less than be required to maneuver to the again of the sphere in the event that they do, eradicating the chance for them to realize a tactical benefit by way of it.
Three years in the past Lando Norris referred to as this “the worst rule ever invented” and plenty of others have questioned it since. If solely a fraction of the hassle expended on the nugatory dash race gimmick had been spent on tidying up this odd contradiction of F1’s racing guidelines.
Or, for that matter, questioning why a long-standing guidelines exception Monaco already enjoys remains to be mandatory. The decrease tyre degradation seen throughout a grand prix in Monaco is partly a consequence of the foundations stipulating this race have to be 45 kilometres shorter (virtually 15%) than every other. So long as F1 bases its races round who could make their tyres final, the one occasion run to lower than the 305 kilometre restrict is all the time going to be at a drawback.
Is it even honest to single Monaco out because the least entertaining grand prix venue? Based on our readers’ Rate the Race votes by the tip of final season, 5 tracks on the 2024 F1 calendar produce constantly much less thrilling races. Even when we low cost these with low pattern sizes comparable to Miami and Losail (two races every) that also leaves the Circuit de Catalunya in Spain, Autodromo Hermanos Rodriguez in Mexico and – worst of all – Yas Marina in Abu Dhabi as F1’s least entertaining venues.
This means these operating F1 could be deluding themselves by considering Monaco is the one observe which produces sub-standard racing. The 2022 guidelines modifications might have introduced the sphere nearer collectively on efficiency, however have they allowed drivers to race nearer collectively? Do drivers nursing high-degradation tyres and performing slam-dunk DRS passes really create thrilling races?
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
By its nature, Monaco reveals the difficulties of F1 racing in extremis. But it surely stays a spectacular and problem venue which may shock and excite in different methods. Those that would invent new guidelines in an effort to make its race extra like every other on the calendar are forgetting that F1 vehicles don’t race particularly nicely at lots of these both.
That is why drivers are clamouring for smaller, lighter chassis. Only some hours earlier than the grand prix Method 2’s drivers demonstrated passing is feasible round Monaco in narrower vehicles.
Have I seen skilled something duller than the 2024 Monaco Grand Prix? Most races in Valencia and Sochi. Spa 2021, little doubt. However nonetheless boring the Monaco Grand Prix could be, I’ve by no means endured one as tedious as listening to the identical whinges and half-baked, knee-jerk options that are dreamt up for it yearly. Overlook about ‘fixing’ Monaco, F1 wants to have a look at the large image.
