Hitting coaches and swing coaches aren’t the identical factor.
I heard these actual phrases, or variations thereof, numerous instances this season whereas speaking to coaches. Extra usually that not, the phrases had been accompanied by an opinion that too many hitters — particularly younger hitters — are overly targeted on honing an ideal swing, whereas what they need to primarily be specializing in is… properly, truly hitting the baseball. That’s to not low cost the significance of excellent swings — each hitting coach understands their worth — however far more goes into squaring up pitches inside a sport surroundings. As San Diego Padres particular assistant Mark Loretta put it in yesterday’s Talks Hitting interview, “Clearly, you must swing to hit the ball, however swinging isn’t hitting.”
Here’s what three MLB basic managers needed to say on the topic, primarily because it pertains to participant growth.
———
Ross Fenstermaker, Texas Rangers GM
The Texas Rangers named a brand new basic supervisor on November 4, selling Ross Fenstermaker from assistant GM/participant growth and worldwide scouting, a task he’d held since October 2021. A College of California Davis graduate, Fenstermaker has been with the group since 2010, initially approaching board as a baseball operations intern.
Given his PD expertise — and with swings in thoughts — I requested Fenstermaker concerning the developments the Rangers made in that space over latest seasons.
“Greater than something, we’ve systematized a whole lot of our processes, issues that we’re in the end making an attempt to have our gamers obtain,” Fenstermaker advised me at this month’s GM Conferences in San Antonio. “We’ve altered a few of our key efficiency indicators and reoriented our gamers towards issues that we worth, issues we all know are main indicators of future main league success. I feel we’re always evolving our processes.”
“At instances there have been pursuits of bat pace and bat pace growth packages,” he continued. “There have additionally been suggestions loops associated to swing selections and high quality of strategy. In the end, we’re emphasizing the issues that we need to worth. On the finish of the day it’s about run creation, so we’re all the time stress testing what we’re emphasizing — whether or not or not it’s resulting in the supposed targets, which is to create runs and create main league gamers.”
Which introduced us to the query I had in thoughts, not only for Fenstermaker, however for different GMs as properly:
How do you steadiness hitting coaches vis-a-vis swing coaches — usually two utterly completely different animals — inside participant growth?
“That’s an awesome query,” he replied.” I feel a whole lot of coaches can do both, and plenty of can do each, nevertheless it’s difficult. You’ve received swing technicians that may actually break down the mechanics of the swing, the best way the physique works, the best way the physique strikes. Then there are extra of the hitting coaches, which I might say are perhaps slightly bit extra psychological in nature. They’re strategy oriented, sport prep, ensuring that the participant is able to not solely swing at their optimum talents, but in addition carry out when the time comes, be capable to fight that pitcher that night.”
His response having served extra as a synopsis of the variations than the kind of reply I used to be in search of, so I adopted up:
How a lot would you like that balanced — hitting coaches versus swing technicians — all through the system? Furthermore, does it differ between ranges, from Rookie Ball as much as Triple-A?
“I feel you need to mix,” Fenstermaker mentioned. “Every participant is completely different. They’re most likely going to wish slightly bit completely different strategy, and we now have very particular, individualized participant plans. On the foundational stage, you need to actually refine gamers’ approaches as finest as potential, realizing that swing modifications, or swing enhancements, alongside the best way are going to occur, whether or not that’s simply pure bodily maturation and growth or if it’s one thing extra hands-on. It could be one thing bigger scale that that you must undertake. However yeah, I feel it’s a mix, and in the end it will depend on the person — prime, backside, backside to prime.”
———
Ben Cherington, Pittsburgh Pirates GM
“We’re making an attempt to do each,” Cherington mentioned of the hitting coach/swing coach steadiness. “We have now people who find themselves targeted on each of these issues. We have now people who find themselves targeted on assessing the motion and designing the coaching surroundings that we predict will assist enhance the best way that guys are transferring, in addition to connecting the work within the weight room to the cage. Then we now have different people who find themselves targeted extra on, ‘How will we prepare for the sport and the way are we going to beat this pitcher?’
“The bottom line is that these persons are related and collaborating with one another, as a result of they do intersect. There’s a relationship between the alternatives you make — the swing selections and the strategy — and the way you’re transferring, and the place your swing is. You may’t work on one in isolation. You must discuss to one another.”
———
Buster Posey, San Francisco Giants GM
“I feel it’s essential to have route, general, for the group,” Posey advised me. “We need to have an id of who we need to be, and what our strategy is. A few of that may play out 12 months to 12 months, based mostly on who’s within the lineup. However yeah, that’s an fascinating query about hitting coach or a swing coach. I personally suppose, from my expertise, that this can be very essential for a hitting coach to be that man who’s all the time transferring up with the power they’re bringing every day. It’s such an extended season. To have the ability to are available in after a troublesome stretch and preserve the blokes motivated and sticking to the plan is essential.”
As with Fenstermaker, a followup for Posey was so as. I requested the All-Star-catcher-turned-executive if gamers arising by way of a minor league system can generally over-focus on their swings, and never sufficient on being “a hitter.”
“I feel thats’ a risk,” Posey replied. “That will be true now [and] it might be true 15 years in the past once I was arising. It will be true most likely way back to you need to go. One of many messages I need our gamers to know is that you have to be your personal finest coach. There may be accountability that comes with that. We have now so many alternative voices giving route, and it’s a great factor, however generally there’s a tendency to let these voices be crutches. You might want to make it recognized, ‘Hey, that you must be accountable for what you’re doing.’ All these coaches. and voices, are a useful resource for you — they’re completely different opinions and you may take it in and filter it — however in the end that you must be liable for your personal profession. That’s to not reduce the significance of coaches. I perceive that coaches are crucial.”
