Who Needs Sellers, Anyway? Orioles, Phillies Swap Hays for Domínguez and Pache

Depend me amongst those that fearful that, with about 12 groups within the Nationwide League playoff hunt within the week earlier than the commerce deadline, there may not be sufficient sellers to kickstart a commerce market. Nicely, the Philadelphia Phillies — who’ve the most effective document in baseball — and the Baltimore Orioles — who’re tied for the most effective document within the American League — have come collectively and mentioned, “To heck with all that.”

The Orioles are sending outfielder Austin Hays north in trade for reliever Seranthony Domínguez and outfielder Cristian Pache. This being a transaction between Baltimore and Philadelphia, I assume there’s a amount of Previous Bay altering palms within the deal, however how a lot is as but unspecified.

An trade of three main leaguers between two first-place groups? Hallelujah, a problem commerce!

Hays, 29, was an All-Star final 12 months, and is hitting .255/.316/.395 in 63 video games this season. It’s a little bit of a step again for a man who was about a median left fielder with high-teens residence run energy for the previous three seasons. However with Anthony Santander having the most effective season of his profession, and with the emergence of Colton Cowser and Heston Kjerstad, outfield enjoying time is fairly exhausting to come back by in Baltimore anymore. (Probably of curiosity solely to me: Between this deal and the commerce of Mike Baumann to Seattle two months ago, the Orioles have now solely liquidated what was as soon as the league’s best assortment of third-round picks from Jacksonville College.)

The Phillies have lengthy been available in the market for an outfielder. The one actual weak spot for Philadelphia is heart discipline. Johan Rojas is a dynamite defender and may outrun his personal shadow, however he’s hitting .231/.268/.295 and has by no means actually proven a lot offensive promise. Brandon Marsh is an excellent defensive left fielder however slightly in need of splendid in heart, and at any price, the Phillies don’t have one other left fielder who can hit in the event that they slide Marsh over. That was alleged to be Whit Merrifield, however everyone knows how that experiment went.

As deep because the Phillies are, and have been, on offense, they’ve lengthy been in want of a right-handed bench bat who might spell both Marsh or Rojas when the crew wanted a run late in video games. Jake Cave, it bears repeating, made the final out of the Phillies’ season final 12 months. Hays fills that want. He’s not a star by any means, however he doesn’t must be.

This commerce may disappoint Phillies followers who’ve spent the previous two months making an attempt to give you a punny Wolf Pack-style nickname for a Luis Robert Jr. fan membership. The Phillies may make one other transfer within the outfield, or they won’t. However buying and selling for Hays doesn’t influence their want for a participant like Robert — or their potential to amass one — within the slightest.

Hays may often begin in left alongside Marsh in heart, however he’s truly an ideal complement for the Phillies’ soggiest and most hirsute starter:

So whereas Hays should do wonders for the Phillies as a fourth outfielder and platoon starter, the necessity in heart discipline stays. Furthermore, neither crew actually gave up something they’re going to overlook.

Domínguez is principally the Austin Hays of aid pitchers. As soon as the Phillies’ nearer of the long run, Domínguez had been within the group since 2011, and this season he broke into the highest 20 in profession aid appearances in franchise historical past. However this Phillies lifer had fallen down the pecking order over the previous two seasons. On the time of the commerce, Domínguez was sixth amongst present Phillies relievers in common leverage index.

Not solely has he trickled down the depth chart like Hays, the 2 gamers have comparable contract statuses. Hays makes $6.3 million this 12 months, with one season of arbitration remaining. Domínguez, who’s additionally 29, makes $4.25 million this 12 months — $3.65 million towards the CBT — with an $8 million membership choice for 2025.

In the most effective bullpen within the Nationwide League, Domínguez is perhaps a low-leverage man. Baltimore’s bullpen can be among the many greatest within the recreation within the mixture, however the Orioles don’t have anybody who’s been as dominant as Jeff Hoffman and Matt Strahm, or Orion Kerkering. Baltimore’s nearer, Craig Kimbrel, was arguably Philadelphia’s least reliable reliever final season.

A part of the issue for Domínguez is that his sinker, one of many hardest in baseball, simply hasn’t been working for him the previous 12 months or so. He’s compensated by throwing his slider extra, and his outcomes on that pitch have been good — a 37.6% whiff price and a .249 opponent wOBA on 40% utilization in 2024 — however plenty of little issues have gone incorrect for Domínguez this 12 months. His strand price is approach down, he’s letting opponents put the ball within the air extra, and after they do, he’s giving up extra residence runs.

However on the finish of the day, this can be a man who throws two completely different fastballs that may hit 100 mph and has a plus slider. If he goes to Baltimore and adjustments completely nothing, he’ll most likely do higher than his present 4.75 ERA, and he’ll throw medium-leverage innings within the playoffs for the Orioles. But when the Orioles can get him again to the place he was in 2022, when his sinker was his greatest pitch as a substitute of a legal responsibility, there’s the potential for a lot, far more.

The third participant within the commerce, Pache, has been a reputation since he was a prospect within the Braves’ system. He’s at all times dazzled defensively, however the A’s (who acquired him within the Matt Olson deal) after which the Phillies (who traded for him final spring) have held out hope that he’d hit sufficient to justify having his glove on the market, solely to come back away upset. For a lot of the previous 12 months, the Phillies carried each Pache and Rojas — two all-glove right-handed heart fielders — on a four-man bench, which by no means made sense to me for an immediate. If the Phillies had made any transfer for a place participant, Pache was most likely first in line not solely to lose his spot on the 26-man roster, however to get DFA’d. Including him to the commerce merely offers the Orioles proper of first refusal for a participant who most likely would’ve ended up on waivers.

With that mentioned, he may very well be helpful. The Orioles have sufficient punch of their lineup that they received’t want Pache to hit, and with Cedric Mullins’ vary on the decline, Baltimore doesn’t have a defensive outfielder of Pache’s caliber. (I just checked, Enrique Bradfield Jr. remains to be in A-ball.) Perhaps he’ll stick as a pinch-runner and defensive alternative, but when not, it’s no huge deal.

Each groups will most likely wish to make additional additions of their pursuit of a World Sequence title, however for the Friday earlier than the deadline, it is sensible to shuffle items round in pursuit of extra modest positive factors. Hays, Domínguez, and Pache can have a number of days to succeed in their new groups — and it’d take that lengthy, shore site visitors in Delaware being what it’s on Friday afternoons in the summertime — whereas the Phillies and Orioles can recalibrate earlier than making their subsequent strikes.